Innovation Isn't Just New Products

Mercantile Growth Partners · Insights · By Michael Chisholm

Ask most consumer companies about their innovation pipeline and you'll get a list of products: new flavors, new sizes, new formulas, line extensions.

New products matter. But if that's the only place a company looks for growth, it's leaving a lot of opportunity on the table.

Some of the most valuable innovation I've been part of didn't involve a new product at all.

Start with the consumer problem

A few years ago, while working with CVS, we kept coming back to a simple insight about allergy sufferers: many of them don't actually know what they're allergic to.

They know they feel miserable at certain times of year, or around certain things. So they try a product, then another, and often end up frustrated. The products weren't the problem. The missing piece was knowledge.

The obvious response for a consumer health company would have been another product. Instead, the opportunity was a service. We helped bring allergy testing into CVS MinuteClinic, so consumers could find out what their triggers actually were and make better decisions about how to manage them.

That solved a real consumer problem. It gave the retailer something genuinely differentiated. And it created a smarter path to the right products, rather than another item competing for the same shelf space.

Innovation can happen anywhere in the consumer journey

The lesson I took from that experience is that innovation can sit almost anywhere between a consumer's need and the moment it gets solved:

  • A service that helps consumers diagnose or understand their problem

  • A capability that makes the product easier to find, choose or use

  • A partnership that brings together strengths neither company has alone

  • A channel that reaches consumers where they already are

  • A commercial model that changes how the product is bought, sold or supported

  • A connection between steps in the journey that used to be disconnected

None of these require a new formula or a new SKU. All of them can create growth, and some create more durable growth than another product would.

Don't start with what you can make

Many companies approach innovation from the inside out: What else can our plants produce? What adjacent product could we launch?

That's understandable. It's where their capabilities and their comfort zone are. But it often leads to products that are easy to make and hard to sell.

The better starting point is outside in: What problem does the consumer still have? Where do they get stuck? What would make their life meaningfully easier? Once you understand that, you can ask what role your company could play in solving it, whether that's a product or something else entirely.

Why this matters for growing brands

For a growing consumer brand, this thinking is a real advantage. Large competitors often have the scale to win the product-versus-product battle on shelf. Smaller brands usually don't.

But growing brands can often move faster, partner more creatively and see consumer problems that bigger organizations overlook. An innovation that changes how consumers discover, choose or use your product can be worth more than another line extension, and it's much harder for a competitor to copy.

It also changes the conversation with retailers. A buyer sees dozens of new items every review. A brand that comes in with a genuine solution to a shopper problem, one that helps the retailer differentiate, stands out.

The takeaway

Innovation is not a product category. It's a way of solving problems.

So here's a question worth asking your team: if you couldn't launch a single new product next year, how would you grow?

Mercantile Growth Partners provides fractional sales leadership for growing consumer products and consumer health businesses. If your growth has outpaced your sales organization, let’s talk!

Next
Next

Revenue Is an Outcome. Manage the Drivers.